On John Dove, Innkeeper, Mauchline
Behind the poem
The mock epitaph asks what religion Johnny Pidgeon followed and answers through a list of drinks. Strong ale performs an ablution, small beer becomes persecution, and port supplies celestial glory. The innkeeper’s imagined creed is measured by the quality of his liquor.[1]
Read the fuller story
Two six-line stanzas move from the puzzle of Johnny’s faith to its exuberant explanation. The religious vocabulary gives the drinking joke its shape. Cunningham identifies John Dove as the keeper of Mauchline’s Whitefoord Arms and explicitly describes the verse as making his religion a comparison among liquors.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
Here lies Johnny Pidgeon; What was his religion? Wha e’er desires to ken, To some other warl’ Maun follow the carl, For here Johnny Pidgeon had nane! Strong ale was ablution— Small beer, persecution, A dram was memento mori ; But a full flowing bowl Was the saving his soul, And port was celestial glory.
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 195