Epistle from Esopus to Maria
Behind the poem
The man who once played Hamlet and Othello now writes from prison, where he says the suffering is real. Cunningham identifies the satirical letter’s speaker as the actor Williamson and Maria as Mrs Riddel. The old performer takes up a new part as a supposedly sympathetic correspondent with an insult ready for almost everyone.[1]
Read the fuller story
The opening crowds the prison with turnkeys, thieves and failed resolutions to reform. From there the speaker moves into recollections of the stage and Maria’s combative social presence. The changing scene allows the poem to attack several people while keeping the fiction of an intimate letter. Cunningham identifies Williamson the actor, Mrs Riddel, Captain Gillespie and Colonel Macdouall among its targets; the last two are also named in the edition’s footnotes.[1]
A long parenthesis repeats accusations against Maria’s verse and describes Burns himself dipping his pen in undiluted gall. That self-reference makes the aggression unusually visible. The insults are presented as things others have said, but repeating them at length becomes a fresh attack. When her poetry is compared to a workhouse for stray ideas, the word “workhouse” abruptly returns Esopus to his own misery. The verbal link lets personal mockery and the prison setting feed each other.[1]
The ending promises a joint campaign against their enemies. Its supposed praise then collapses: Esopus boasts of prose which defeats deciphering and a tongue which defeats every reply. Alliance becomes another way of exposing vanity. The rhyming pairs and final three-line rhyme give this mock pledge a pointed finish. Cunningham says he printed the epistle from the poet’s manuscript and describes it as an outpouring of wrath and contempt. His account identifies the satire’s occasion and targets broadly; the prison scenes and accusations remain part of its hostile dramatic construction.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
“Motley foundling fancies, stolen or strayed;” “Still matchless tongue that conquers all reply.”] From those drear solitudes and frowsy cells, Where infamy with sad repentance dwells; Where turnkeys make the jealous portal fast, And deal from iron hands the spare repast; Where truant ‘prentices, yet young in sin, Blush at the curious stranger peeping in; Where strumpets, relics of the drunken roar, Resolve to drink, nay, half to whore, no more; Where tiny thieves not destin’d yet to swing, Beat hemp for others, riper for the string: From these dire scenes my wretched lines I date, To tell Maria her Esopus’ fate. “Alas! I feel I am no actor here!” ’Tis real hangmen, real scourges bear! Prepare, Maria, for a horrid tale Will turn thy very rouge to deadly pale; Will make they hair, tho’ erst from gipsy polled, By barber woven, and by barber sold, Though twisted smooth with Harry’s nicest care, Like hoary bristles to erect and stare. The hero of the mimic scene, no more I start in Hamlet, in Othello roar; Or haughty Chieftain, ‘mid the din of arms, In Highland bonnet woo Malvina’s charms; While sans culottes stoop up the mountain high, And steal from me Maria’s prying eye. Blest Highland bonnet! Once my proudest dress, Now prouder still, Maria’s temples press. I see her wave thy towering plumes afar, And call each coxcomb to the wordy war. I see her face the first of Ireland’s sons, And even out-Irish his Hibernian bronze; The crafty colonel leaves the tartan’d lines, For other wars, where he a hero shines; The hopeful youth, in Scottish senate bred, Who owns a Bushby’s heart without the head; Comes, ‘mid a string of coxcombs to display That veni, vidi, vici, is his way; The shrinking bard adown the alley skulks, And dreads a meeting worse than Woolwich hulks; Though there, his heresies in church and state Might well award him Muir and Palmer’s fate: Still she undaunted reels and rattles on, And dares the public like a noontide sun. (What scandal call’d Maria’s janty stagger The ricket reeling of a crooked swagger, Whose spleen e’en worse than Burns’ venom when He dips in gall unmix’d his eager pen,— And pours his vengeance in the burning line, Who christen’d thus Maria’s lyre divine; The idiot strum of vanity bemused, And even th’ abuse of poesy abused! Who call’d her verse, a parish workhouse made For motley foundling fancies, stolen or stray’d?) A workhouse! ah, that sound awakes my woes, And pillows on the thorn my rack’d repose! In durance vile here must I wake and weep, And all my frowsy couch in sorrow steep; That straw where many a rogue has lain of yore, And vermin’d gipsies litter’d heretofore. Why, Lonsdale, thus thy wrath on vagrants pour? Must earth no rascal save thyself endure? Must thou alone in guilt immortal swell, And make a vast monopoly of hell? Thou know’st, the virtues cannot hate thee worse, The vices also, must they club their curse? Or must no tiny sin to others fall, Because thy guilt’s supreme enough for all? Maria, send me too thy griefs and cares; In all of thee sure thy Esopus shares. As thou at all mankind the flag unfurls, Who on my fair one satire’s vengeance hurls? Who calls thee, pert, affected, vain coquette, A wit in folly, and a fool in wit? Who says, that fool alone is not thy due, And quotes thy treacheries to prove it true? Our force united on thy foes we’ll turn, And dare the war with all of woman born: For who can write and speak as thou and I? My periods that deciphering defy, And thy still matchless tongue that conquers all reply.
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 184
About this edition
Digital transcription of the collected edition, including the introduction and two identifying footnotes.
Written by Burns
Cunningham says he printed the epistle from the poet’s manuscript and identifies its personal targets.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the satirical epistle spoken by Esopus
Cunningham, Complete Works of Robert Burns (Boston, 1855), CXXXIII, p. 184; retained HTML #CXXXIII.