The Kirk’s Alarm. A Ballad. Second Version
Behind the poem
The Kirk’s defenders march out after Dr M’Gill with much noise and a battery of spiritual guns. “Rumble John”, “Simper James” and “Davie Bluster” are among the names called out, with the name and final line repeated after each new insult. Cunningham prints this version as seventeen numbered stanzas and a postscript.[1]
Read the fuller story
His introduction says the text came from Miss Logan of Afton’s papers. It also quotes a letter presented as Burns’s account to Graham of Fintry. In that extract, the poet defends M’Gill as worthy and able, describes the danger to his family, and admits that the enclosed ballad is very local. He finds some of its conceits amusing while acknowledging heavy stanzas. Read through Cunningham’s quotation, this gives the satire both a humane occasion and an author capable of questioning his own performance.[1]
The ballad’s mock alarm turns opposition to the Doctor into a campaign against sense itself. Its defenders of orthodoxy carry spiritual guns supplied by hard hearts and leaden skulls. Their preaching becomes a roar, their pursuit a hunt. Short repeated names—“Rumble John”, “Simper James”, “Davie Bluster”—keep the personal targets at the front of the verse. The Scots vocabulary adds to the physical comedy: a fox in the fold becomes a “tod i’ the fauld”, and a would-be pursuer who cannot bite can still bark.[1]
The final numbered stanza calls on “Poet Burns”, bringing the maker of the satire into its own roll-call. The postscript then turns from attack to circulation, asking Afton’s Laird for a copy to be passed to Clackleith. Cunningham supplies a later printed history too, naming Stewart’s 1801 publication and quoting Cromek’s dismissive judgement. The manuscript route and publishing claims remain his account. Within the ballad, the repeated refrains and request for another copy show a work imagined as something people could remember, repeat and pass on.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
Orthodox, orthodox, Who believe in John Knox, Let me sound an alarm to your conscience— There’s a heretic blast, Has been blawn i’ the wast, That what is not sense must be nonsense, Orthodox, That what is not sense must be nonsense. Doctor Mac, Doctor Mac, Ye should stretch on a rack, And strike evil doers wi’ terror; To join faith and sense, Upon any pretence, Was heretic damnable error, Doctor Mac, Was heretic damnable error. Town of Ayr, town of Ayr, It was rash I declare, To meddle wi’ mischief a-brewing; Provost John is still deaf, To the church’s relief, And orator Bob is its ruin, Town Of Ayr, And orator Bob is its ruin. D’rymple mild, D’rymple mild, Tho’ your heart’s like a child, And your life like the new-driven snaw, Yet that winna save ye, Old Satan must have ye For preaching that three’s are an’ twa, D’rymple mild, For preaching that three’s are an’ twa. Calvin’s sons, Calvin’s sons, Seize your spiritual guns, Ammunition ye never can need; Your hearts are the stuff, Will be powder enough, And your skulls are a storehouse of lead, Calvin’s sons, And your skulls are a storehouse of lead. Rumble John, Rumble John, Mount the steps with a groan, Cry the book is with heresy cramm’d; Then lug out your ladle, Deal brimstone like aidle, And roar every note o’ the damn’d, Rumble John, And roar every note o’ the damn’d. Simper James, Simper James, Leave the fair Killie dames, There’s a holier chase in your view; I’ll lay on your head, That the pack ye’ll soon lead, For puppies like you there’s but few, Simper James, For puppies like you there’s but few. Singet Sawnie, Singet Sawnie, Are ye herding the penny, Unconscious what danger awaits? With a jump, yell, and howl, Alarm every soul, For Hannibal’s just at your gates, Singet Sawnie, For Hannibal’s just at your gates. Andrew Gowk, Andrew Gowk, Ye may slander the book, And the book nought the waur—let me tell you; Tho’ ye’re rich and look big, Yet lay by hat and wig, And ye’ll hae a calf’s-head o’ sma’ value, Andrew Gowk, And ye’ll hae a calf’s-head o’ sma’ value. Poet Willie, Poet Willie, Gie the doctor a volley, Wi’ your “liberty’s chain” and your wit; O’er Pegasus’ side, Ye ne’er laid a stride Ye only stood by when he ——, Poet Willie, Ye only stood by when he ——. Barr Steenie, Barr Steenie, What mean ye? what mean ye? If ye’ll meddle nae mair wi’ the matter, Ye may hae some pretence, man, To havins and sense, man, Wi’ people that ken ye nae better, Barr Steenie, Wi’ people that ken ye nae better. Jamie Goose, Jamie Goose, Ye hae made but toom roose, O’ hunting the wicked lieutenant; But the doctor’s your mark, For the L—d’s holy ark, He has cooper’d and ca’d a wrong pin in’t, Jamie Goose, He has cooper’d and ca’d a wrong pin in’t. Davie Bluster, Davie Bluster, For a saunt if ye muster, It’s a sign they’re no nice o’ recruits, Yet to worth let’s be just, Royal blood ye might boast, If the ass were the king o’ the brutes, Davie Bluster, If the ass were the king o’ the brutes. Muirland George, Muirland George, Whom the Lord made a scourge, To claw common sense for her sins; If ill manners were wit, There’s no mortal so fit, To confound the poor doctor at ance, Muirland George, To confound the poor doctor at ance. Cessnockside, Cessnockside, Wi’ your turkey-cock pride, O’ manhood but sma’ is your share; Ye’ve the figure, it’s true, Even our faes maun allow, And your friends daurna say ye hae mair, Cessnockside, And your friends daurna say ye hae mair. Daddie Auld, Daddie Auld, There’s a tod i’ the fauld A tod meikle waur than the clerk; Tho’ ye downa do skaith, Ye’ll be in at the death, And if ye canna bite ye can bark, Daddie Auld, And if ye canna bite ye can bark. Poet Burns, Poet Burns, Wi’ your priest-skelping turns, Why desert ye your auld native shire? Tho’ your Muse is a gipsy, Yet were she even tipsy, She could ca’ us nae waur than we are, Poet Burns, She could ca’ us nae waur than we are. Afton’s Laird, Afton’s Laird, When your pen can be spar’d, A copy o’ this I bequeath, On the same sicker score I mentioned before, To that trusty auld worthy Clackleith, Afton’s Laird, To that trusty auld worthy Clackleith.
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 163
About this edition
Digital transcription of the 1855 collected edition. Seventeen numbered stanzas precede the postscript.
Written by Burns
Cunningham presents this ballad from Miss Logan’s papers and quotes Burns discussing its local satire.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the second ballad version and postscript