Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

← Poems & songs

Fragment inscribed to the Right Hon. C.J. Fox

Behind the poem

Charles James Fox, the politician to whom Burns addresses the fragment, has the knowledge and judgment to make a success of things and the passions and imagination to spoil them. From that double-edged compliment Burns moves to a larger question. How much of anyone’s conduct can be explained by a single trait?[1]

Read the fuller story

The speaker then turns from this individual to humanity at large. A person’s depths, shallows, good and evil would puzzle even the devil. The poem mocks the attempt to explain character through one ruling passion, associating that system with Pope. Its image of a show-box makes the theory look mechanically simple: pull a string and the picture appears. The objection is that human variety refuses such easy operation.[1]

Even similar virtues cannot safely be assumed to travel together. The poem insists that possessing one quality does not prove possession of another, however closely related they appear. This gives the opening praise and blame a more substantial purpose. Fox’s contradictions become an example of the difficulty of reducing a person to a single moral description.[1]

The final turn abandons abstraction for political combat. The speaker asks his patron to leave the struggle for laurels against “Billy”, a rival represented as willing to trade, smuggle or steal his way to victory. The last joke makes the contest one of out-thieving rather than outdoing. It ends the displayed fragment with an accusation whose force depends on satire’s extravagant picture of ambition.[1]

Cunningham’s introduction describes a change in Burns’s opinion of Fox and connects it with disappointed hopes from the Tories and continuing hopes from the Whigs. That explanation of political allegiance is the later editor’s account. The fragment itself offers a more unstable tribute: admiration, teasing criticism, philosophical resistance to simple categories and partisan attack all share the same address.[1]

Story references
  1. Cunningham, Complete Works of Robert Burns (Boston, 1855), section C, printed pp. 156–157; retained digital HTML #C.

Poem

Cunningham (1855)

How wisdom and folly meet, mix, and unite;
How virtue and vice blend their black and their white;
How genius, th’ illustrious father of fiction,
Confounds rule and law, reconciles contradiction—
I sing: if these mortals, the critics, should bustle,
I care not, not I—let the critics go whistle!

But now for a patron, whose name and whose glory
At once may illustrate and honour my story.

Thou first of our orators, first of our wits;
Yet whose parts and acquirements seem mere lucky hits;
With knowledge so vast, and with judgment so strong,
No man with the half of ‘em e’er went far wrong;
With passions so potent, and fancies so bright,
No man with the half of ‘em e’er went quite right;—
A sorry, poor misbegot son of the muses,
For using thy name offers fifty excuses.

  Good L—d, what is man? for as simple he looks,
Do but try to develope his hooks and his crooks;
With his depths and his shallows, his good and his evil,
All in all he’s a problem must puzzle the devil.

On his one ruling passion Sir Pope hugely labours,
That, like th’ old Hebrew walking-switch, eats up its neighbours;
Mankind are his show-box—a friend, would you know him?
Pull the string, ruling passion the picture will show him.
What pity, in rearing so beauteous a system,
One trifling particular, truth, should have miss’d him;
For spite of his fine theoretic positions,
Mankind is a science defies definitions.

Some sort all our qualities each to its tribe,
And think human nature they truly describe;
Have you found this, or t’other? there’s more in the wind,
As by one drunken fellow his comrades you’ll find.

But such is the flaw, or the depth of the plan,
In the make of that wonderful creature, call’d man,
No two virtues, whatever relation they claim,
Nor even two different shades of the same,
Though like as was ever twin brother to brother,
Possessing the one shall imply you’ve the other.

But truce with abstraction, and truce with a muse,
Whose rhymes you’ll perhaps, Sir, ne’er deign to peruse:
Will you leave your justings, your jars, and your quarrels,
Contending with Billy for proud-nodding laurels.
My much-honour’d Patron, believe your poor poet,
Your courage much more than your prudence you show it;
In vain with Squire Billy, for laurels you struggle,
He’ll have them by fair trade, if not, he will smuggle;
Not cabinets even of kings would conceal ‘em,
He’d up the back-stairs, and by G—he would steal ‘em.
Then feats like Squire Billy’s you ne’er can achieve ‘em;
It is not, outdo him, the task is, out-thieve him.

Digital text from Project Gutenberg.

View the source edition · p. 156

About this edition

The complete displayed fragment is retained with Cunningham’s introduction.

Project Gutenberg ebook licence notice

Written by Burns

Cunningham presents the fragment as Burns’s and relates it to his changing opinion of Fox.

Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the verse fragment addressed to Fox

Cunningham, Complete Works of Robert Burns (Boston, 1855), section C, pp. 156–157; retained digital HTML #C.

← Poems & songs