First Epistle to Robert Graham, Esq., of Fintray
Behind the poem
Nature makes the poet from such restless, fiery stuff that the slightest breath can scatter it. The joke is part of an appeal to Robert Graham of Fintray. Burns can amuse his friends with verse and still struggle to earn a living. Cunningham links the letter to his request for a post in the Excise near home.[1]
Read the fuller story
The poet’s peculiar constitution supplies the case for assistance. He can delight his serious friends and receive their praise while lacking the means to live. His wish to ease others’ sorrow coexists with the neglect of his own. Nature therefore finds him a supporting tree: the generous person to whom this vulnerable climbing plant can attach itself. Graham enters the poem at precisely that point, as the support the speaker openly asks to grasp.[1]
The praise of generosity is also a criticism of calculated goodness. Those who give only by rule and continually postpone action are contrasted with people who enjoy the act of bestowing. The appeal seeks a sympathetic relationship as well as practical aid. Its descriptions of poets as unworldly and generous form part of that persuasive argument; the speaker is making a case for his own kind.[1]
The final movement reveals how uncomfortable the request remains. The speaker fears being classed with writers whose verse boasts of independence while their private conduct is servile and demanding. The rising lark that ends on the ground supplies an image of the fall between elevated words and behaviour. He declares himself willing to take up the plough and patch his jacket again before accepting that degradation. Yet the conclusion renews the request: support may allow the muse to strengthen her wing for a higher flight.[1]
Cunningham’s introduction connects the epistle with a request for an Excise appointment near Burns’s home. He says Graham had promised a place, that Burns had qualified, and that anxiety about farming led him to seek the appointment. Cunningham also reports the eventual division’s extent as ten parishes. Those circumstances come through the later editor’s account of the accompanying letter and manuscript. The verse gives the request its emotional shape, moving from a comic origin of poets to the delicate business of accepting help while retaining self-respect.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
When Nature her great master-piece designed, And fram’d her last, best work, the human mind, Her eye intent on all the mazy plan, She form’d of various parts the various man. Then first she calls the useful many forth; Plain plodding industry, and sober worth: Thence peasants, farmers, native sons of earth, And merchandise’ whole genus take their birth: Each prudent cit a warm existence finds, And all mechanics’ many-apron’d kinds. Some other rarer sorts are wanted yet, The lead and buoy are needful to the net; The caput mortuum of gross desires Makes a material for mere knights and squires; The martial phosphorus is taught to flow, She kneads the lumpish philosophic dough, Then marks th’ unyielding mass with grave designs, Law, physic, politics, and deep divines: Last, she sublimes th’ Aurora of the poles, The flashing elements of female souls. The order’d system fair before her stood, Nature, well pleas’d, pronounc’d it very good; But ere she gave creating labour o’er, Half-jest, she tried one curious labour more. Some spumy, fiery, ignis fatuus matter, Such as the slightest breath of air might scatter; With arch alacrity and conscious glee (Nature may have her whim as well as we, Her Hogarth-art perhaps she meant to show it) She forms the thing, and christens it—a Poet. Creature, tho’ oft the prey of care and sorrow, When blest to-day, unmindful of to-morrow. A being form’d t’amuse his graver friends, Admir’d and prais’d—and there the homage ends: A mortal quite unfit for fortune’s strife, Yet oft the sport of all the ills of life; Prone to enjoy each pleasure riches give, Yet haply wanting wherewithal to live; Longing to wipe each tear, to heal each groan, Yet frequent all unheeded in his own. But honest Nature is not quite a Turk, She laugh’d at first, then felt for her poor work. Pitying the propless climber of mankind, She cast about a standard tree to find; And, to support his helpless woodbine state, Attach’d him to the generous truly great, A title, and the only one I claim, To lay strong hold for help on bounteous Graham. Pity the tuneful muses’ hapless train, Weak, timid landsmen on life’s stormy main! Their hearts no selfish stern absorbent stuff, That never gives—tho’ humbly takes enough; The little fate allows, they share as soon, Unlike sage proverb’d wisdom’s hard-wrung boon. The world were blest did bliss on them depend, Ah, that “the friendly e’er should want a friend!” Let prudence number o’er each sturdy son Who life and wisdom at one race begun, Who feel by reason and who give by rule, (Instinct’s a brute, and sentiment a fool!) Who make poor will do wait upon I should — We own they’re prudent, but who feels they’re good? Ye wise ones, hence! ye hurt the social eye! God’s image rudely etch’d on base alloy! But come ye who the godlike pleasure know, Heaven’s attribute distinguished—to bestow! Whose arms of love would grasp the human race: Come thou who giv’st with all a courtier’s grace; Friend of my life, true patron of my rhymes! Prop of my dearest hopes for future times. Why shrinks my soul half blushing, half afraid, Backward, abash’d to ask thy friendly aid? I know my need, I know thy giving hand, I crave thy friendship at thy kind command; But there are such who court the tuneful nine— Heavens! should the branded character be mine! Whose verse in manhood’s pride sublimely flows, Yet vilest reptiles in their begging prose. Mark, how their lofty independent spirit Soars on the spurning wing of injur’d merit! Seek not the proofs in private life to find; Pity the best of words should be but wind! So to heaven’s gates the lark’s shrill song ascends, But grovelling on the earth the carol ends. In all the clam’rous cry of starving want, They dun benevolence with shameless front; Oblige them, patronize their tinsel lays, They persecute you all your future days! Ere my poor soul such deep damnation stain, My horny fist assume the plough again; The pie-bald jacket let me patch once more; On eighteen-pence a week I’ve liv’d before. Tho’, thanks to Heaven, I dare even that last shift! I trust, meantime, my boon is in thy gift: That, plac’d by thee upon the wish’d-for height, Where, man and nature fairer in her sight, My muse may imp her wing for some sublimer flight.
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 152
About this edition
Cunningham associates the appeal with a request for a nearby Excise appointment.
Written by Burns
Cunningham connects the epistle with Burns’s request to Graham for an Excise appointment near his home.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the first verse epistle to Robert Graham