Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

← Poems & songs

To Captain Riddel, of Glenriddel. Extempore lines on returning a Newspaper

Behind the poem

Captain Riddel gets his newspaper back with a verse thanking him for the loan. Even the crimes scarcely merit a mention, Burns says. The reviewers fare worse. He likens them to men who can judge a stone or a patch of mortar and have no eye for the finished building. [1]

Read the fuller story

The critics become “chippers and hewers”, competent to judge mortar and stone but unable to assess a finished building. The distinction is between handling separate materials and understanding the work they form together. “Meet or unmeet” means fitting or unfitting: the speaker claims that the reviewers cannot properly judge the fitness of the completed fabric. Architecture supplies a compact image for critical judgment that misses the whole.[1]

The last stanza changes the direction of the wit. Instead of measuring other writers’ shortcomings, the poet finds his own pen inadequate to express Riddel’s kindness. A goose-quill would need the power of a sunbeam to make that goodness known throughout the world. The extravagant compliment ends a practical exchange with warmth. Repeated addresses to “Sir”, long lines carrying internal rhymes, and shorter answering lines keep the verse close to spirited conversation.[1]

Cunningham’s heading calls the lines extempore, and the dateline gives Ellisland on a Monday evening. His introduction identifies Riddel as Burns’s neighbour at Friars-Carse and praises his hospitality and antiquarian interests. The suggestion that the borrowed periodical contained attacks on Burns is explicitly something Cunningham had heard. That report offers a possible occasion for the middle stanza. The verse itself joins a general complaint about reviewers to a distinctly personal acknowledgment of the lender’s generosity.[1]

Story references
  1. Cunningham, Complete Works of Robert Burns (Boston, 1855), section XCI, printed p. 152; retained digital HTML #XCI.

Poem

Cunningham (1855)

Your news and review, Sir, I’ve read through and through, Sir,
  With little admiring or blaming;
The papers are barren of home-news or foreign,
  No murders or rapes worth the naming.

Our friends, the reviewers, those chippers and hewers,
  Are judges of mortar and stone, Sir,
But of meet or unmeet in a fabric complete ,
  I’ll boldly pronounce they are none, Sir.

My goose-quill too rude is to tell all your goodness
  Bestow’d on your servant, the Poet;
Would to God I had one like a beam of the sun,
  And then all the world, Sir, should know it!

Digital text from Project Gutenberg.

View the source edition · p. 152

About this edition

The editorial account of criticism in the borrowed periodical is qualified as hearsay.

Project Gutenberg ebook licence notice

Written by Burns

Cunningham presents the lines as Burns’s return of a periodical to his neighbour Captain Riddel; the reported criticism within it is hearsay.

Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the verse note returning a newspaper

Cunningham, Complete Works of Robert Burns (Boston, 1855), section XCI, p. 152; retained digital HTML #XCI.

← Poems & songs