Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

← Poems & songs

On scaring some Water-fowl in Loch Turit

Behind the poem

Birds scatter when the speaker approaches Loch Turit. He calls them “tenants of the lake” and wonders why their families should have to flee from him. Soon he is asking how human beings can prize their own freedom and claim the right to master other creatures. [1]

Read the fuller story

The question soon turns back upon humanity. The speaker blushes for his own species as he recognises the cause of the birds’ fear. Human beings claim freedom for themselves while seeking mastery over everything around them. The poem compresses that accusation into the figure of a creature proud of liberty and tyrannical towards others. Its political vocabulary gives the disturbance at the water’s edge a larger moral reach.[1]

An eagle provides the crucial comparison. It hunts because necessity compels it; a human can boast of compassion while killing for pleasure. The poem’s argument depends on that difference between predation and chosen recreation. Its rebuke is especially sharp because it uses humanity’s own claim to a humane heart as the measure of its conduct.[1]

The last movement returns to the birds’ remote surroundings and their means of escape. If human power invades their ‘native right’, they can take to the air and seek another lake. Their flight, initially read as fear, becomes a kind of refusal. The closing appeal urges them to scorn slavery even when they cannot confront their pursuer. The noise of their wings carries the poem from apology towards defiance.[1]

Cunningham places the composition during a Highland tour when Burns was staying with Sir William Murray of Ochtertyre. He describes Loch-Turit as a lonely hill lake. That later account provides the setting; the forty-line poem develops its own argument through direct address and rhyming pairs. A brief encounter with disturbed birds becomes a demand that human kindness extend beyond the human community.[1]

Story references
  1. Robert Burns, The Complete Works, with Allan Cunningham’s editorial notes (1855), ‘On Scaring some Water-fowl in Loch-Turit’, section LXXXV, printed pp. 148–149; retained Project Gutenberg digital edition.

Poem

Cunningham (1855)

Why, ye tenants of the lake,
For me your wat’ry haunt forsake?
Tell me, fellow-creatures, why
At my presence thus you fly?

Why disturb your social joys,
Parent, filial, kindred ties?—
Common friend to you and me,
Nature’s gifts to all are free:
Peaceful keep your dimpling wave,
Busy feed, or wanton lave:
Or, beneath the sheltering rock,
Bide the surging billow’s shock.

Conscious, blushing for our race,
Soon, too soon, your fears I trace.
Man, your proud usurping foe,
Would be lord of all below:
Plumes himself in Freedom’s pride,
Tyrant stern to all beside.

The eagle, from the cliffy brow,
Marking you his prey below,
In his breast no pity dwells,
Strong necessity compels:
But man, to whom alone is giv’n
A ray direct from pitying heav’n,
Glories in his heart humane—
And creatures for his pleasure slain.

In these savage, liquid plains,
Only known to wand’ring swains,
Where the mossy riv’let strays,
Far from human haunts and ways;
All on Nature you depend,
And life’s poor season peaceful spend.

Or, if man’s superior might
Dare invade your native right,
On the lofty ether borne,
Man with all his pow’rs you scorn;
Swiftly seek, on clanging wings,
Other lakes and other springs;
And the foe you cannot brave,
Scorn at least to be his slave.

Digital text from Project Gutenberg.

View the source edition · p. 148

About this edition

Cunningham’s introduction places the poem during a stay at Ochtertyre on a Highland tour.

Project Gutenberg ebook licence notice

Written by Burns

Cunningham specifically describes Burns writing these lines during his stay with Sir William Murray of Ochtertyre.

Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the poem

Section LXXXV, introduction

← Poems & songs