Verses written under the Portrait of the Poet Fergusson
Behind the poem
Below Robert Fergusson’s portrait, Burns takes the reader to task for enjoying a poet’s work while letting him starve. He calls Fergusson his elder brother in misfortune and, by far, his elder brother in poetry. The lines went into a copy of Fergusson’s works given to a young woman in Edinburgh. [1]
Read the fuller story
The address then becomes personal. Burns calls Fergusson his ‘elder brother in misfortune’, before strengthening the kinship: ‘By far my elder brother in the muses’. The second phrase acknowledges poetic seniority as well as shared suffering. Its emphatic ‘By far’ makes admiration part of the mourning. The speaker approaches the portrait as a fellow poet who also recognises a master.[1]
Tears and pity lead into the final question. Why should the bard, so responsive to the world’s pleasures, receive so little compassion from it? The lines leave that imbalance unresolved. Their movement from curse to brotherhood and then to a question gives the short inscription the force of an appeal to the reader’s conscience. Enjoying the poems becomes an occasion to think about the person who made them.[1]
The heading in Cunningham’s edition places the verses beneath Fergusson’s portrait in a copy of his works presented to a young lady. Cunningham gives the date as Edinburgh, 19 March 1787, and leaves the recipient unnamed. The gift’s setting matters: this is an encounter between poets carried into another reader’s book. Burns’s tribute joins literary admiration to a demand that the pleasure of reading should carry sympathy for its author.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
Curse on ungrateful man, that can be pleas’d, And yet can starve the author of the pleasure! O thou my elder brother in misfortune, By far my elder brother in the muses, With tears I pity thy unhappy fate! Why is the bard unpitied by the world, Yet has so keen a relish of its pleasures?
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 144
About this edition
The heading describes its position beneath Fergusson’s portrait in a gift volume.
Written by Burns
Cunningham presents the inscription as Burns’s gift-book tribute to Fergusson and dates it to Edinburgh in March 1787.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the inscription