To John Goudie of Kilmarnock
Behind the poem
John Goudie publishes his essays and suddenly Bigotry is on her last legs. Superstition, Orthodoxy and Enthusiasm follow her to the sickbed. In congratulating the Kilmarnock writer, Burns imagines his opponents calling in the doctors and coming up with a cure more alarming than their complaints. [1]
Read the fuller story
The title connects the address with the publication of Goudie’s essays. Cunningham’s headnote places them in the Macgill controversy and reports that Stewart published this poem with “The Jolly Beggars” in 1801. The poem itself concentrates on the shock caused by Goudie’s arguments, making their effect visible through a brisk succession of sickbeds.[1]
Bigotry appears first, sour-faced and on her last legs. Even in retreat she wishes the ten Egyptian plagues upon Goudie. Superstition then gapes and stares while a physician is summoned to examine her urine, a medical detail which brings the grand abstraction down to an undignified bodily condition. The repeated cries of concern sustain a mock sympathy for beliefs the poem is exposing to ridicule.[1]
Orthodoxy gasps at the throat, and Enthusiasm has a galloping consumption. The accelerating illnesses make resistance appear increasingly hopeless. Doctors become quacks whose knowledge cannot restore their patient. Each six-line stanza develops a little scene, with its shorter fourth and sixth lines giving the symptoms and verdict a sharp comic finish.[1]
The closing accusation names Goudie and Taylor as the chief causes of the trouble; the source footnote identifies Taylor as Dr Taylor of Norwich. The supposed sufferers’ supporters have another remedy ready: an empty tar barrel and two burning peats. Read against the charges of religious mischief, this is a threat of fiery punishment directed at the critics. The poem’s final joke exposes the violence within its opponents’ imagined answer to argument. Their cure would end the quarrel by attacking the people who began it.[1]
Poem
Cunningham (1855)
XXVIII.
TO
JOHN GOUDIE OF KILMARNOCK.
ON THE PUBLICATION OF HIS ESSAYS
O Goudie! terror of the Whigs, Dread of black coats and rev’rend wigs, Sour Bigotry, on her last legs, Girnin’, looks back, Wishin’ the ten Egyptian plagues Wad seize you quick. Poor gapin’, glowrin’ Superstition, Waes me! she’s in a sad condition: Fie! bring Black Jock, her state physician, To see her water: Alas! there’s ground o’ great suspicion She’ll ne’er get better. Auld Orthodoxy lang did grapple, But now she’s got an unco ripple; Haste, gie her name up i’ the chapel, Nigh unto death; See, how she fetches at the thrapple, An’ gasps for breath. Enthusiasm’s past redemption, Gaen in a gallopin’ consumption, Not a’ the quacks, wi’ a’ their gumption, Will ever mend her. Her feeble pulse gies strong presumption Death soon will end her. ’Tis you and Taylor[44] are the chief, Wha are to blame for this mischief, But gin the Lord’s ain focks gat leave, A toom tar-barrel, An’ twa red peats wad send relief, An’ end the quarrel.
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · Cunningham 1855, p. 97; retained digital section XXVIII
About this edition
Cunningham edition footnotes
[44] Dr. Taylor, of Norwich.
Cunningham’s editorial introduction: [This burning commentary, by Burns, on the Essays of Goudie in the Macgill controversy, was first published by Stewart, with the Jolly Beggars, in 1801; it is akin in life and spirit to Holy Willie’s Prayer; and may be cited as a sample of the wit and the force which the poet brought to the great, but now forgotten, controversy of the West.]
Poem attributed to Burns by Cunningham
Cunningham describes the address as Burns’s commentary on Goudie’s essays and reports its later publication. This account supplies the attribution used here.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the satirical address