Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

← Poems & songs

Remorse. A Fragment

Behind the poem

Cunningham prints Burns’s agreement with the author of The Theory of Moral Sentiments: it takes unusual fortitude to bear pain you have brought on yourself and still admit the harm you have done. In the poem the worst thought is that another person’s love and trust might have made them easier to hurt. Peace depends on a serious intention to change. [1]

Read the fuller story

Cunningham prints the work as a fragment and places a prose statement attributed to Burns above it. That statement agrees with the author of the Theory of Moral Sentiments about the exceptional pain of remorse. It distinguishes fortitude under an innocent misfortune from the harder task of bearing self-inflicted suffering while retaining a proper sense of wrongdoing. The verse develops much the same problem through accusation, physical sensation and an urgent question.[1]

The opening sorts misfortunes according to responsibility. When suffering comes from outside, the mind can answer that the deed was not its own. Folly removes that comfort, adding the sting of self-reproach to the original trouble. Guilt goes further still: its consciousness tortures and gnaws. These verbs turn an abstract moral condition into something which attacks the sufferer from within.[1]

The decisive turn is towards other people. The speaker imagines having involved the young and innocent, whose affection has made them vulnerable. Their very love may have caused their ruin. The word “perhaps” leaves open the fearful possibility that another person’s trust has become the means of hurting them.[1]

The cry to “burning hell” measures that inward punishment against the worst torments the speaker can imagine. After the longer lines, “There’s not a keener lash!” strikes abruptly. The poem then changes from declaring pain to asking whether anyone can master it. A guilty heart still throbs with horror, but reason may quiet the agitation after a proper purpose of amendment: a serious intention to change one’s conduct.[1]

The final exclamations envy the person capable of that recovery. “Magnanimity” here names greatness of soul in facing guilt and governing the resulting turmoil. Peace comes after the intention to amend, so the sequence keeps responsibility within the hoped-for recovery. The fragment closes with admiration for a difficult moral strength, its repeated “happy” sounding almost astonished at the possibility.[1]

Story references
  1. Robert Burns, “Remorse. A Fragment”, in The Complete Works of Robert Burns, with explanatory and glossarial notes by Allan Cunningham (1855), p.71, section XIII: complete fragment and preceding editorial quotation, retained Project Gutenberg digital transcription.

Poem

Cunningham (1855)

XIII.

REMORSE.

A FRAGMENT.

Of all the numerous ills that hurt our peace,
That press the soul, or wring the mind with anguish,
Beyond comparison the worst are those
That to our folly or our guilt we owe.
In every other circumstance, the mind
Has this to say, ‘It was no deed of mine;’
But when to all the evil of misfortune
This sting is added—‘Blame thy foolish self!’
Or worser far, the pangs of keen remorse;
The torturing, gnawing consciousness of guilt,—
Of guilt, perhaps, where we’ve involved others;
The young, the innocent, who fondly lov’d us,
Nay, more, that very love their cause of ruin!
O burning hell! in all thy store of torments,
There’s not a keener lash!
Lives there a man so firm, who, while his heart
Feels all the bitter horrors of his crime,
Can reason down its agonizing throbs;
And, after proper purpose of amendment,
Can firmly force his jarring thoughts to peace?
O, happy! happy! enviable man!
O glorious magnanimity of soul!

Excerpt from the Project Gutenberg text.

View the source edition · Cunningham 1855, p. 71; retained digital edition

About this edition

Cunningham edition footnotes

Cunningham’s editorial introduction: [“I entirely agree,” says Burns, “with the author of the Theory of Moral Sentiments, that Remorse is the most painful sentiment that can embitter the human bosom; an ordinary pitch of fortitude may bear up admirably well, under those calamities, in the procurement of which we ourselves have had no hand; but when our follies or crimes have made us wretched, to bear all with manly firmness, and at the same time have a proper penitential sense of our misconduct, is a glorious effort of self-command.”]

Project Gutenberg ebook licence notice

Fragment attributed to Burns by Cunningham

Cunningham presents Remorse as a fragment by Burns and places a prose statement attributed to him before it. The prose and verse remain separate.

Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the fragment

Cunningham 1855, p. 71; retained digital edition

← Poems & songs