Had I a cave on some wild distant shore
Behind the song
The grieving lover would like a cave on a distant coast where he can weep within earshot of the waves. Then he turns on the woman who broke her vows and asks how she expects to find peace herself. Cunningham ties the song to the unhappy love affair of Alexander Cunningham and prints it to “Robin Adair”. [1]
Read the fuller story
The first stanza seeks the furthest possible retreat. Wind and crashing waves would surround a solitary mourner, whose lost peace seems recoverable only through tears and, finally, death. The long opening lines give way to shorter phrases, narrowing the imagined scene towards its final silence.[1]
The second stanza replaces solitude with direct address. The speaker challenges the woman to explain promises now treated as insubstantial as air. He imagines her going to another lover and laughing over her broken oath, then ends by asking what peace she can find within herself. That question turns the desired repose of the first stanza into a moral challenge in the second.[1]
The headnote supplies a personal occasion and a date of 1793, presenting Alexander Cunningham’s experience through the editor’s account. The grieving speaker moves from withdrawal to angry confrontation across the two stanzas.[1]
Lyrics
Choose an edition
Cunningham (1855)
Had I a cave on some wild, distant shore, Where the winds howl to the waves’ dashing roar; There would I weep my woes, There seek my lost repose, Till grief my eyes should close, Ne’er to wake more. Falsest of womankind, canst thou declare, All thy fond plighted vows—fleeting as air! To thy new lover hie, Laugh o’er thy perjury, Then in thy bosom try What peace is there!
Digital text from Project Gutenberg.
View the source edition · p. 283
About this edition
Cunningham’s preface discusses several poems he left out of the collection.
Dick (1903) · no. 7
View the source edition · no. 7; p. 5