You Ask Me, Charming Fair
Behind the song
Asked why he looks so troubled, a lover tells the woman he addresses that her own charms explain his distress. Her kindness to everyone makes her indifference to his love especially painful.[1]
Read the fuller story
He believes his feelings are plain to see: his colour changes and his breast heaves, defeating his attempts at concealment. Yet she seems to treat his passion as another passing infatuation. In the closing stanza he claims he could have endured anger or scorn more easily than this lack of response. The complaint remains his account of an affection she has not returned.[1]
The Museum commentary attributes the song to William Hamilton of Bangour. It leaves the melody’s composer unidentified, preserving a distinction between the credited words and their setting.[2]
Story references
- The Scotish Musical Museum, 1839 edition, volume VI, no. 565, “You ask me charming fair”, printed p. 584; retained PDF page 84. Complete five eight-line stanzas.
- The Scotish Musical Museum, accompanying note DLXV, printed p. 488; retained PDF page 170. Hamilton of Bangour attribution and unidentified melody composer.
Lyrics
Scots Musical Museum, vol. VI (1839) · no. 565
You ask me charming fair.
You ask me charming fair Why thus I pensive go, From whence proceeds my care What nourishes my woe. Why seek'st the cause to find Of ills that I endure Ah! why so vainly kind Unless resolv'd to cure. It needs no magic arts, To know whence my alarms, Examine your own heart, Go read them in your charms. Whene'er the youthful quoir, Along the vale advance, To raise, at your desire, The lay, or form the dance. Beneficent to each, You some kind grace afford, Gentle in deed or speech, A smile or friendly word. Whilst on my love you put No value; On the same, As if my fire was but Some paltry village flame. At this my colour flies, My breast with sorrow heaves, The pain I would disguise, Nor man nor maid deceives. My love stands all display'd, Too strong for art to hide, How soon the heart's betray'd With such a clue to guide! How cruel is my fate, Affronts I could have born, Found comfort in your hate, Or triumph'd in your scorn. But whilst I thus adore, I'm driv'n to wild despair; Indifference is more Than raging love can bear.
View the source edition · You ask me charming fair.; p. 584