Willy's Rare and Willy's Fair
Behind the song
Praise of Willy and his promise of marriage give way to an empty bed and a searching voice. The short fragment ends with the discovery of his drowned body in Yarrow.
Read the fuller story
The opening piles up Willy’s attractions: he is rare, fair and wonderfully bonny. His promise to marry the speaker carries its own anxious qualification, repeated in the musical underlay. In the next stanza the bed that was made broad will now be narrow, because the winter night is spent without a companion.
The search moves out through the landscape. Questions about the waterside, roses, lilies and the green meadow lead to the direct question of whether anyone has seen Willy. East and west, broad and narrow, the searching ends at a crag and the river. The discovery is abrupt; the fragment closes with Willy drowned.
The Museum commentary says that this old fragment came from Thomson’s Orpheus Caledonius of 1725. It also quotes an additional stanza remembered by the editor, in which the woman uses her golden hair to draw Willy from Yarrow. That stanza is outside the selected printed lyric. The note traces later related ballads and a separate altered version set by James Hook, showing how the little fragment generated further writing.
Lyrics
Scots Musical Museum, vol. VI (1839) · no. 525
Willy's rare, and Willy's fair.
Willy's rare, and Willy's fair, And Willy's wond'rous bonnie; and Willy heght to marry me gin e'er he marry'd ony oh gin e'er he marry'd ony. Yestreen I made my bed fu' brade, The night I'll make it narrow; For a' the live lang winters night, I lie twin'd of my marrow. O came you by yon water side, Pu'd you the rose or lily; Or came you by yon meadow green, Or saw you my sweet Willy? She sought him east, she sought him west She sought him brad and narrow: Sine in the clifting of a craig, She found him drown'd in Yarrow.
Fragment from the 1839 edition.
View the source edition · Willy's rare, and Willy's fair.; p. 542
About this edition
Complete printed fragment from the 1839 edition.