The Trogger
Behind the song
‘The Trogger’ tells of a journey towards the Border and a sexual encounter in which the speaker's resistance is ignored. Its recurring curse gives the account a continuing note of anger, even as the story moves on to shared drink and another encounter. The ending returns to bodily discomfort and the same condemnation.[1]
Read the fuller story
The meeting takes place beside the Annan, among rough banks and slopes. At first the speaker thinks the man's behaviour is a joke; the realisation that he is forcing intercourse changes that understanding. The stanza ends by calling down the devil on such ‘troggin’. The refrain makes the speaker's judgement part of every stage of the story.[1]
The second stanza asks what could be said or done, then describes cursing, abuse and a prohibition which makes the man more forceful. His physical actions continue against that resistance. The wording gives the refusal a central place in the account. The song gives the scene an exaggerated bawdy rhythm while keeping the speaker's objection explicit.[1]
The final stanza moves along a named route: Ecclefechan, drink in company, and the slopes of Bonshaw before parting. A further sexual encounter is followed by a complaint of continuing soreness. Its closing curse carries the discomfort beyond the journey.[1]
The 1911 editors label the song anonymous and suggest that it is probably no older than Burns's time. They point to Scott Douglas for a quoted stanza and an opinion on authorship, without reproducing that opinion here. Individual authorship remains unresolved.[1]
The tune heading is ‘Gillicrankie’. Three eight-line stanzas end with the same curse, and masked words remain part of this edition's text. ‘Scroggie’ means rough with scrub, ‘stane’ stone and ‘sin’ syne’ since then. That last phrase matters to the ending: the narrator describes a consequence which continues after the travelling pair have separated.[1]
Story references
- The Merry Muses of Caledonia, Burns Federation edition (1911), pp. 50, complete selected text and accompanying editorial note.
Sources
- The Merry Muses of Caledonia (1911), p. 50