To J. S****
Behind the poem
Visiting Jamie has worn out twenty pairs of the poet’s shoes. The joke opens an affectionate verse letter that ranges over the pleasures of rhyme, the risk of poverty and obscurity, and the prospect of growing old. Towards the end Burns lays into people who live by solemn rules, then checks himself and turns back to his friend. [1]
The 1786 Kilmarnock edition calls him ‘J. S****’. A later edition gives his name as James Smith. [1][3]
Read the fuller story
The Kilmarnock volume of 1786 heads the poem “To J. S****”. A three-line epigraph credited to Blair praises friendship as the bond of society. The surname stays masked in this printing, while the closing address supplies Jamie. In the opening, he is a cunning thief with something like a magical warrant over human hearts. Even the joke about his small stature becomes praise: Nature has made amends by putting the qualities of a man into every feature.[1][2]
The speaker asks for a little leisure to hear what is coming. That invitation makes the poem feel like talk between friends, although its twenty-nine six-line stanzas are carefully shaped. Three long rhyming lines lead into a short fourth, followed by another long line and a short conclusion. The brief endings give assertions and jokes a crisp landing. “I rhyme for fun” arrives after a list of less attractive reasons for writing, including money, gossip and attacks on neighbours.[1]
Pleasure in making verse soon meets uncertainty about its audience. A little country wit seems to compensate for poor clothes and scant money, but the prospect of appearing in print provokes an imagined warning. Learned poets have expected future generations to owe them a debt, only to leave pages which moths destroy. The speaker briefly abandons the hope of laurels and imagines singing among fields before dying unknown. Then he interrupts his own melancholy: they are alive and well now, so care can be thrown overboard and enjoyment can fill the sails.[1]
The poem keeps testing that cheerful choice. Pleasure makes hours pass like minutes, yet age threatens to end drinking, wandering and love. Some people receive comfort without working for it; others chase fortune steadily and achieve a settled life. The speaker places himself among those who zig-zag without a rule or road. His defence of freedom therefore includes a glimpse of its cost: obscurity, hunger and the possibility of regret. Each renewed call to sing has something real to overcome.[1]
A comic prayer establishes the wealth he values. Rich food, fine clothes, titles and financial returns can go to others; he asks for abundant rhymes and genuine wit. The Muses are invited to say grace over his scant meal. Scots expressions make this imagined household tangible: “rowth” is abundance, while “water-brose” suggests a very plain dish. The poem turns literary inspiration into company at the table, sustaining the same appetite for sociability that opened the letter.[1]
Its closing attack on respectable dullness uses musical language. The rule-bound people never wander into the trills and graces of “arioso”; they hum solemn basses “gravissimo”. These terms describe contrasting temperaments, giving the lively voice an imagined freedom of movement beside their heavy gravity. A standing pool and a dyke supply equally still images for their hearts and lives. Before the mockery carries him further, the speaker checks himself and turns back to Jamie. The poem’s answer to uncertainty is finally a pair of companions travelling together.[1]
Story references
- Robert Burns, Poems, chiefly in the Scottish dialect (Kilmarnock, 1786), “To J. S****”, pp.69–78 (PDF76–85): complete 174-line poem and three-line epigraph credited to Blair.
- Burns, Poems, chiefly in the Scottish dialect (Kilmarnock, 1786), title and imprint (PDF8).
- Robert Burns, Poems and Songs of Robert Burns, “Epistle to James Smith”. Project Gutenberg transcription.
Poem
Choose an edition
Kilmarnock Poems (1786)
TO J. S****.
DEAR S****, the sleest, pawkie thief, That e’er attempted stealth or rief, Ye surely hae some warlock-breef Owre human hearts; For ne’er a bosom yet was prief Against your arts. For me, I swear by sun an’ moon, And ev’ry star that blinks aboon, Ye’ve cost me twenty pair o’ shoon Just gaun to see you; And ev’ry ither pair that’s done, Mair taen I’m wi’ you. That auld, capricious carlin, Nature, To mak amends for scrimpet stature, She’s turn’d you off, a human-creature On her first plan, And in her freaks, on ev’ry feature, She’s wrote, the Man. Just now I’ve taen the fit o’ rhyme, My barmie noddle’s working prime, My fancy yerket up sublime Wi’ hasty summon: Hae ye a leisure-moment’s time To hear what’s comin? Some rhyme a neebor’s name to lash; Some rhyme, (vain thought!) for needfu’ cash; Some rhyme to court the countra clash, An’ raise a din; For me, an aim I never fash; I rhyme for fun. The star that rules my luckless lot, Has fated me the russet coat, An’ damn’d my fortune to the groat; But, in requit, Has blest me with a random-shot O’ countra wit. This while my notion’s taen a sklent, To try my fate in guid, black prent; But still the mair I’m that way bent, Something cries, “Hoolie! “ I red you, honest man, tak tent! Ye’ll shaw your folly. “ There’s ither Poets, much your betters, “ Far seen in Greek, deep men o’ letters, “ Hae thought they had ensur’d their debtors, “ A’ future ages; “ Now moths deform in shapeless tatters, “ Their unknown pages.” Then farewel hopes of Laurel-boughs, To garland my poetic brows! Henceforth, I’ll rove where busy ploughs Are whistling thrang, An’ teach the lanely heights an’ howes My rustic sang. I’ll wander on with tentless heed, How never-halting moments speed, Till fate shall snap the brittle thread; Then, all unknown, I’ll lay me with th’ inglorious dead, Forgot and gone! But why, o’ Death, begin a tale? Just now we’re living sound an’ hale; Then top and maintop croud the sail, Heave Care o’er-side! And large, before Enjoyment’s gale, Let’s tak the tide. This life, sae far’s I understand, Is a’ enchanted fairy-land, Where Pleasure is the Magic-wand, That, wielded right, Maks Hours like Minutes, hand in hand, Dance by fu’ light. The magic-wand then let us wield; For, ance that five an’ forty’s speel’d, See, crazy, weary, joyless Eild, Wi’ wrinkl’d face, Comes hostan, hirplan owre the field, Wi’ creeping pace. When ance life’s day draws near the gloamin, Then fareweel vacant, careless roamin; An’ fareweel chearfu’ tankards foamin, An’ social noise; An’ fareweel dear, deluding woman, The joy of joys! O Life! how pleasant in thy morning, Young Fancy’s rays the hills adorning! Cold-pausing Caution’s lesson scorning, We frisk away, Like school-boys, at th’ expected warning, To joy and play. We wander there, we wander here, We eye the rose upon the brier, Unmindful that the thorn is near, Among the leaves; And tho’ the puny wound appear, Short while it grieves. Some, lucky, find a flow’ry spot, For which they never toil’d nor swat; They drink the sweet and eat the fat, But care or pain; And haply, eye the barren hut, With high disdain. With steady aim, Some Fortune chase; Keen hope does ev’ry sinew brace; Thro’ fair, thro’ foul, they urge the race, And sieze the prey: Then canie, in some cozie place, They close the day. And others, like your humble servan’, Poor wights! nae rules nor roads observin; To right or left, eternal swervin, They zig-zag on; Till curst with Age, obscure an’ starvin, They aften groan. Alas! what bitter toil an’ straining— But truce with peevish, poor complaining! Is Fortune’s fickle Luna waning? E’en let her gang! Beneath what light she has remaining, Let’s sing our Sang. My pen I here fling to the door, And kneel, ‘ Ye Pow’rs, and warm implore, ‘ Tho’ I should wander Terra o’er, ‘ In all her climes, ‘ Grant me but this, I ask no more, ‘ Ay rowth o’ rhymes. ‘ Gie dreeping roasts to countra Lairds, ‘ Till icicles hing frae their beards; ‘ Gie fine braw claes to fine Life-guards, ‘ And Maids of Honor; ‘ And yill an’ whisky gie to Cairds, ‘ Until they sconner. ‘ A Title, DEMPSTER merits it; ‘ A Garter gie to WILLIE PIT; ‘ Gie Wealth to some be-ledger’d Cit, ‘ In cent per cent; ‘ But give me real, sterling Wit, ‘ And I’m content. ‘ While ye are pleas’d to keep me hale, ‘ I’ll sit down o’er my scanty meal, ‘ Be’t water-brose, or muslin-kail, ‘ Wi’ chearfu’ face, ‘ As lang’s the Muses dinna fail ‘ To say the grace. An anxious e’e I never throws Behint my lug, or by my nose; I jouk beneath Misfortune’s blows As weel’s I may; Sworn foe to sorrow, care, and prose, I rhyme away. O ye, douse folk, that live by rule, Grave, tideless-blooded, calm and cool, Compar’d wi’ you—O fool! fool! fool! How much unlike! Your hearts are just a standing pool, Your lives, a dyke! Nae hare-brain’d, sentimental traces, In your unletter’d, nameless faces! In arioso trills and graces Ye never stray, But gravissimo, solemn basses Ye hum away. Ye are sae grave, nae doubt ye’re wise; Nae ferly tho’ ye do despise The hairum-scairum, ram-stam boys, The rambling squad: I see ye upward cast your eyes— —Ye ken the road— Whist I—but I shall haud me there— Wi’ you I’ll scarce gang ony where— Then Jamie, I shall say nae mair, But quat my sang, Content with YOU to mak a pair, Whare’er I gang.
Complete verse epistle: 174 lines in twenty-nine stanzas, with the three-line epigraph credited to Blair.
View the source edition · pp. 69–78
About this edition
The 1786 printing keeps the addressee’s surname masked and addresses Jamie in its closing stanza.
Edinburgh Poems (1787)
View the source edition · pp. 108–117
Burns’s own writing
Burns wrote this verse epistle, published in his 1786 Kilmarnock Poems. The separate opening epigraph is credited to Blair.
Words Robert Burns
Burns’s role Author of the verse epistle; separate epigraph credited to Blair