Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

1878

Douglas retracts a story

The Works of Robert Burns, volume fourth, Prose, with a small engraved figure and the Edinburgh imprint dated 1878.Open full image
The title page of the prose volume in William Scott Douglas’s edition of Burns, published in 1878.
Historical edition · 1878 · Internet Archive · Licence · Source

William Scott Douglas withdrew a story about Margaret Kennedy when his fourth volume of Robert Burns's works appeared in 1878. He had earlier repeated Robert Chambers's account that Peggy's misfortune was discussed at Dr Lawrie's manse in 1786. Douglas now argued that the affair had remained secret until the birth of her child in 1794.

The correction affected a familiar explanation of Ye Banks and Braes. Later readers had connected its betrayed lover with Peggy, whom Burns had praised in Young Peggy. Yet Burns sent Alexander Cunningham a draft of the Doon song in March 1791, three years before the public crisis Douglas described.

Douglas's account also followed Peggy's attempt to establish a marriage with Andrew McDouall and secure her daughter's position. Douglas’s retraction put the public dispute after the letter in which Burns sent the song to Cunningham. The story that Peggy inspired it rested on later accounts.

Sources
  1. The Works of Robert Burns, volume IV: Prose · ScottDouglasIV1878 pp103–104,withdrawal ofvolumeII account
  2. NTS Burns to Cunningham11March1791 BRN/01/50 · Burns toCunningham11March1791 BRN/01/50

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading