Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

About 1872

A misleading 1827 date

The title page of The Merry Muses of Caledonia, naming the Crochallan Fencibles and the Burns Federation, dated 1911.Open full image
The Burns Federation’s 1911 title page for The Merry Muses of Caledonia and A Vindication of Robert Burns.
Historical edition · 1911 · Internet Archive · Licence · Source

An edition of The Merry Muses of Caledonia bearing the date 1827 was probably published around 1872, according to editor Valentina Bold. The discrepancy makes its title page a poor guide to when this particular version entered circulation. By then the collection had already acquired a complicated publishing history under Robert Burns's name.

The earliest surviving edition dates from 1799, after Burns's death. Its title names neither an author nor a printer, and its songs draw on a mixture of material. Burns had collected and revised bawdy songs as well as writing some himself. Later publishers could obscure those distinctions by presenting the whole book as his work.

Bold places the book dated 1827 among the editions issued long after Burns had collected and revised the songs. By then, publishers had changed both the selection of songs and the claims they made about who wrote them.

Sources
  1. Valentina Bold On editing The Merry Muses; deposited author text · Bold OneditingTheMerryMuses depositedtext PDFpp7–14,1827/c1872discussion
  2. A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century:1786–1802 · Lamont2017 entry49 pp80–82

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading