Open full imageBurns Federation, 1911 · Internet Archive · Licence · Source
A letter dated 9 June 1871, quoted in the 1911 Merry Muses, reports the destruction of manuscripts associated with Robert Burns’s bawdy songs. Greenshields of Kerse told the editor William Scott Douglas that he had burned material from the Pickering collection on moral grounds.
The 1911 editor discusses the episode while questioning how earlier writers had assigned songs to Burns. Douglas had received transcripts and information from Greenshields, but acknowledged that he had not seen the manuscripts themselves. The reported destruction left later readers dependent on what had already been copied or described.
The 1911 editor used Greenshields’s reported letter in a dispute about which bawdy songs could be attributed to Burns and what could be published under his name. The surviving quotation cannot reconstruct the contents of the destroyed papers or settle the authorship of every song associated with them.
Sources
- The Merry Muses of Caledonia · introxxiv–xxv