Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

24 October 1815

Publishers explain their understanding

A printed page with correspondence about editing Burns, including the opening of the publishers’ letter of 24 October 1815.Open full image
Cadell and Davies’s letter to Gilbert Burns of 24 October 1815, printed in the Burns Chronicle in 1898.
Burns Chronicle · 1898 · Toronto/IA · Licence · Source

The publishers Cadell and Davies replied to Gilbert Burns on 24 October 1815 about a disputed permission. Gilbert had objected to the way Robert Hartley Cromek's Reliques of Robert Burns had appeared. The publishers said that Cromek had assured them of Gilbert's approval.

The disagreement mattered because Gilbert was being asked to help prepare another edition of his brother's works. He wanted control over the material selected under his name. Having supplied recollections and assistance to earlier editors, he was concerned about what readers might assume he had authorised.

Gilbert’s understanding differed from what the publishers said Cromek had told them. The letters show Gilbert and the publishers trying to agree who could decide what the next edition would contain. When these letters appeared in the Burns Chronicle in 1898, readers could follow a dispute that the title page of a completed edition would scarcely reveal.

Sources
  1. Annual Burns Chronicle and Club Directory, No. VII · AnnualBurnsChronicleVII1898 EarnockManuscripts pp13–16,24October1815reply

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading