Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

8 September 1815

Gilbert sets conditions

A printed page of Gilbert Burns’s proposals for selecting letters and adding explanatory notes.
Part of Gilbert Burns’s letter to Cadell and Davies of 20 February 1816, printed in the Burns Chronicle in 1898.
Burns Chronicle · 1898 · Toronto/IA · Source · Licence

Gilbert Burns set conditions before agreeing to help prepare a new edition of his brother Robert's works. Writing to the publishers Cadell and Davies on 8 September 1815, he wanted responsibility for the material selected under his name. He had contributed to James Currie's earlier edition and knew how family testimony could pass through an editor's hands.

Robert Hartley Cromek's Reliques was a particular grievance. Gilbert believed it had appeared without the opportunity for review that he should have been given. The publishers' invitation to make a new and improved edition therefore raised questions about authority as well as the supply of additional material.

Gilbert was Robert’s brother, and his own statements had appeared in the published account of Robert’s life. His reply asked the publishers to recognise that involvement in a collection carried responsibility for its contents. In that first reply Gilbert set out who he thought should decide what went before readers.

Sources
  1. Annual Burns Chronicle and Club Directory, No. VII · AnnualBurnsChronicleVII1898 EarnockManuscripts pp13–16,8September1815letter

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading