Open full imageG. Ross Roy Collection · University of South Carolina Libraries · Licence · Source
A collection called The Merry Muses of Caledonia appeared with the date 1799, three years after Robert Burns’s death. Its title described songs selected for the Crochallan Fencibles, an Edinburgh convivial club associated with Burns’s circle. The title named neither Burns as author nor a printer.
The book gathered bawdy songs with tune directions, including familiar titles in forms that differed from those in ordinary song collections. Burns had participated in collecting, revising and circulating such material among friends, but the published volume contained songs that had been written or adapted by different people.
Later editions added material and changed the book’s presentation, sometimes encouraging readers to treat everything as Burns’s own work. The 1799 title page gives no author. For each song there are separate questions about who wrote or adapted the words, who passed them on and which tune the book names.
Sources
- A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century:1786–1802 · entry 49 pp 80–82
- A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century:1786–1802 · entry 49 p 80
- A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century:1786–1802 · entry 49 contentspp 80–82:9,25,28–29,32,112