Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

1794

Competing tune histories

The song title, tune name and opening three lines of musical notation.Open full image
The opening of Ye Banks and Braes with Caledonian Hunt’s Delight, in James C. Dick’s song collection of 1903.
James C. Dick, 1903 · National Library of Scotland · Licence · Source

Robert Burns recommended The Caledonian Hunt’s Delight to the song collector George Thomson and repeated competing accounts of how its melody had begun. The letter is placed in 1794. Burns knew it as the air suited to the song now familiar as Ye Banks and Braes.

One story came through the musician Stephen Clarke. James Miller had supposedly tried to invent a Scots tune by playing on a harpsichord’s black keys, and Clarke had improved the result. Burns also reported claims of an Irish origin and of a melody brought from the Isle of Man.

Burns felt able to recommend the air whatever its origin. He had already worked through different versions of the words and now passed on three accounts of the melody.

Sources
  1. The Complete Works of Robert Burns: poems, songs and correspondence · CCCIV,pp 484–485

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading