Open full imageJames C. Dick · 1903 · NLS · Licence · Source
Robert Burns sent Alexander Cunningham a newly sketched song on 11 March 1791. It began Sweet are the banks, the banks o' Doon. Burns apologised for the extra sheet of postage and asked his friend to judge what he had written that evening.
He already had a musical plan. The words were intended for Ballendalloch's Reel, an air he also knew as Cambdelmore, and he explained how the short stanzas fitted its phrasing. He hoped to give the song to James Johnson for the fourth volume of the Scots Musical Museum.
The lyric moves from a flowering riverbank to the pain of betrayed affection. Its bird, rose and thorn would recur as Burns revised the song into other versions, including the familiar Ye Banks and Braes. The letter shows which tune Burns had in mind when he first asked Cunningham for criticism, before the later words and setting became familiar.
Sources
- NTS Burns to Cunningham11March1791 BRN/01/50 · LettertoCunningham11March1791 NTSBRN/01/50
- The Songs of Robert Burns: now first printed with the melodies for which they were written · Dicknotes121–123 pp391–393