Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

February 1791

Tytler’s criticism

Burns sits at a desk with a quill and a loose printed sheet in a pool of window light.
Burns correcting a proof for the Edinburgh poems, in an imagined scene.
AI-assisted illustration · AIRT

Alexander Fraser Tytler offered criticism of Tam o’ Shanter while Robert Burns was preparing the poem for readers in 1791. Burns’s February reply agreed to remove lines attacking lawyers and priests. Their tongues and hearts had appeared among the grotesque horrors inside Alloway kirk.

Another suggestion, concerning the ending, was harder to satisfy. Burns considered the criticism but struggled to find an alteration that preserved the effect he wanted. Tytler had been able to read the poem and propose changes before it went into print.

The tale follows a farmer riding home from Ayr, who interrupts a witches’ dance and escapes on his mare, Maggie. It was supplied for Francis Grose’s antiquarian account of Alloway church. Tytler’s advice arrived as Burns was deciding what to keep in the printed poem.

Sources
  1. The Complete Works of Robert Burns: poems, songs and correspondence · letterCCVI,February 1791

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading