Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

6 November 1787

A song received and praised

Gordon Castle beyond parkland, with riders, walkers and dogs in the foreground.Open full image
Gordon Castle in a nineteenth-century print after Thomas Allom, dated to the 1840s.
After Thomas Allom,1840s; public domain. · Licence · Source

James Hoy sent Robert Burns the song words Burns had requested after his visit to Gordon Castle. Burns replied from Edinburgh on 6 November 1787, thanking him and praising the Duke of Gordon's song. James Johnson was sending books as directed, and Burns enclosed the publisher's thanks.

Burns admired the freedom and happiness of expression he found in the best Scottish songs. He placed the duke's work beside that of John Skinner, author of Tullochgorum, and Alexander Ross of Lochlee, while recalling Allan Ramsay and Robert Fergusson. His praise led to a challenge for anyone who considered songwriting an easy occupation: they should try doing it themselves.

He wanted to repay Hoy's kindness with unpublished verses and promised to send some before leaving Edinburgh. Burns’s thanks to Hoy came with an account of why he admired the song. A request made for Johnson's Scots Musical Museum had brought a contribution that Burns valued, and an opportunity to explain the artistic skill he heard in Scottish song.

Sources
  1. The Complete Works of Robert Burns: poems, songs and correspondence · Cunningham1855, letterLXXXIV, 6November1787; complete letter
  2. The Complete Works of Robert Burns: poems, songs and correspondence · Cunningham1855, letterLXXXII, 20October1787 request

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading