Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

11 November 1780

Learning to argue at the Bachelors’ Club

Whitewashed thatched building with red shutters beside the street.Open full image
The Bachelors’ Club building in Tarbolton, in a modern photograph by Roger Griffith.
Roger Griffith · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Licence · Source

The young men who founded Tarbolton’s Bachelors’ Club began with a question about marriage and money. Should a farmer without a fortune choose a wealthy woman capable of running a farmhouse, or an agreeable woman who had no fortune? The club’s history dates this first meeting to 11 November 1780 and names Robert Burns as its president that evening.

Robert and his brother Gilbert were among seven founders. Their debates offered companionship and intellectual exercise alongside working lives. Members took opposing sides of the room, spoke in turn and heard the president’s opinion after both sides had made their case.

The rules protected discussion from interruption and ridicule. Private conversations brought penalties, while revealing another member’s speech to make him a laughing-stock could lead to expulsion. Questions later addressed friendship, education and happiness. At these meetings Burns and his neighbours could work out an argument, hear the other side and test their opinions.

Sources
  1. The works of Robert Burns; with an account of his life, volume I · Currie 1800 I pp 108–109
  2. The works of Robert Burns; with an account of his life, volume I · Currie 1800 I pp 109
  3. The works of Robert Burns; with an account of his life, volume I · Currie 1800 I,pp 106–110,120–121;AppendixII NoteC pp 365–369

Find this stop on the travelling timeline

Further reading