Open full imageHistorical edition · 1911 · Internet Archive · Licence · Source
The Burns Federation published an edition of The Merry Muses of Caledonia in 1911 with an openly defensive purpose. Printed for subscribers and marked not for sale, it promised to vindicate Robert Burns against later books and accusations associated with his name. The introduction was signed Vindex.
Its editor attacked publishers who had added material to the collection and writers who used bawdy songs to condemn Burns. The edition also acknowledged changing some indelicate titles. In trying to recover the songs, the editors made choices of their own about what readers would see.
The earliest edition, dated 1799, had appeared after Burns's death and named no author or printer on its title page. Later versions blurred the distinction between songs he wrote, revised or collected. The Federation edition tried to defend his reputation by challenging those additions, and in doing so produced a version of the collection shaped by those arguments.
Sources
- The Merry Muses of Caledonia · MerryMuses1911 title/introduction xvii–xxiii,xxviii–xxix
- A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century:1786–1802 · Lamont2017 entry49 pp80–82