Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

Tam o’ Shanter: a tale for an antiquary

Francis Grose was collecting the antiquities of Scotland when Burns supplied him with a story for Alloway kirk. The ruined church stood close to the landscape of Burns’s childhood. In the poem, it becomes the place where a farmer riding home from Ayr interrupts a gathering of witches and has to flee for his life.1

Burns’s letter to Grose preserves several supernatural tales associated with the kirk. One concerns a man and a cauldron; another follows a Carrick farmer home from Ayr, past witches dancing to a devil’s music. His shout at a dancer brings pursuit, and his horse escapes across the water at the cost of its tail. A third story sends a traveller far away through the magical use of ragwort. Burns was passing on a group of local narratives from which an antiquary could draw.1

The second contains much of the outline of Tam o’ Shanter. Burns gave it a leisurely beginning before the sudden chase. Tam stays drinking while the market town empties and the road home grows more dangerous. His wife Kate’s warnings are already in the reader’s mind. Beside the fire, with Souter Johnny close by, he has every reason he wants for staying a little longer. The narrator shares the enjoyment, then interrupts it with the thought of pleasure disappearing as soon as it is grasped.2

Once Tam rides out, the pace changes. The journey passes places associated with deaths and frightening stories; thunder and lightning bring the kirk into view. Inside, the dance gathers speed. Burns moves between the grotesque objects around the church and Tam’s increasingly absorbed attention to Nannie. When he shouts his approval, the light goes out and everyone is after him.2

Maggie makes the escape. The narrator urges her towards the bridge, explaining the belief that supernatural pursuers cannot cross the running stream. Nannie reaches for Tam, catches the mare’s tail and tears it away. The ending leaves Maggie carrying the physical cost of her rider’s adventure. A mock warning about drink and short shirts returns the reader to Tam’s appetites, after a chase in which the horse has done the useful work.2

By February 1791 the poem was being discussed and circulated in proof. Burns thanked Alexander Fraser Tytler for criticism and agreed to remove a passage attacking lawyers and priests. Those lines had placed their tongues and hearts among the horrors in the kirk. He found another suggestion, concerning the conclusion, harder to satisfy. The correspondence shows him listening closely while deciding what he could alter without losing the effect he wanted.3

In the same month he sent John Moore a proof from a small supply Grose had provided. A surviving copy at the Robert Burns Birthplace Museum is catalogued as one of that dozen. The poem appeared in Grose’s Antiquities of Scotland, volume II, with the account of Alloway church. Bill Dawson’s study argues that Grose’s publication in parts preceded the Edinburgh periodical printings. The publication history begins in 1791, with the antiquarian project and the circulating proofs already closely connected.45

The poem also changed the purpose of the local story. Grose wanted material connected with an old building; Burns supplied named characters, domestic complaints, comic companionship and a narrator whose sympathies keep shifting. Kate sees the danger before Tam does. Tam sees the dance and forgets it. Maggie brings him home with the evidence of how close he came to losing more than an evening.2

Sources

1. Allan Cunningham, The Complete Works of Robert Burns (1855), Burns to Francis Grose, letter CCXXX. The edition’s 1792 heading is unreliable; the narrative here uses the letter’s contents without adopting that date.

2. Cunningham (1855), Tam o’ Shanter, CXVIII, pp. 171–174, including the variant lines.

3. Cunningham (1855), Burns to Alexander Fraser Tytler, February 1791, letter CCVI.

4. National Trust for Scotland, Tam o’ Shanter, 1791 proof, NTS02/25/BRN02/02; Cunningham, Burns to John Moore, February 1791, CCIX.

5. Craig Lamont, A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century (2017), entry 18, p. 34; Bill Dawson, “The First Publication of ‘Tam o’ Shanter’” (2014), abstract.