Burns in Edinburgh: people, books and unfinished business
In February 1787, Robert Burns was trying to get his subscribers' names to the printer and his portrait ready for the front of his book. He told his friend John Ballantyne that he expected to appear in print within days. The volume eventually appeared in April. Meanwhile, introductions, visits and the business of publication filled his time.1
He had come to Edinburgh late in 1786 after the success of his Kilmarnock poems. Thomas Blacklock's encouragement helped make another edition seem possible. By December Burns was reporting friends among the city's professors and writers, support from titled patrons, and negotiations with the bookseller William Creech. His first Edinburgh winter brought a larger readership and a new circle of acquaintances. Later visits involved collecting money, gathering songs and sustaining friendships as he arranged his return to farming.2
A room in the Lawnmarket
John Richmond, an acquaintance from Mauchline, gave Burns somewhere to stay. Richmond later told the Edinburgh antiquary Robert Chambers that they shared one room and one bed in Mrs Carfrae's house in Baxter's Close, off the Lawnmarket. Chambers passed the recollection to Burns's biographer John Gibson Lockhart, who printed it in 1828. It supplies a small, domestic view of the first winter: Burns's Edinburgh life depended partly on the help of someone he already knew.3
His correspondence soon needed a business address. In December he asked friends to send letters through Creech's bookshop. There was news to report. Patrick Miller had anonymously left ten guineas for him at James Sibbald's; Burns discovered the donor's identity and accepted an invitation to his house. Miller would later become his landlord at Ellisland. Burns credited Dalrymple of Orangefield with introducing him to the Earl of Glencairn, whose help secured support from the Caledonian Hunt.2
He also named Hugh Blair, Dugald Stewart and Henry Mackenzie among his literary friends. These relationships brought opportunity and scrutiny. In the same letter that listed his supporters, Burns worried about being exposed too suddenly to fashionable and learned attention. He could welcome assistance while feeling uneasy about the speed of his celebrity.2
Making and selling the book
Creech was the bookseller; William Smellie printed the edition. Its title page presented the venture as printed for the author and sold by Creech. The frontispiece carried John Beugo's engraving after Alexander Nasmyth's portrait. A reader met Burns's likeness, his dedication to the Caledonian Hunt and the subscribers' names before reaching the poems.4
The subscribers connected Edinburgh to readers elsewhere. Orders might pass through a friend or bookseller who gathered names and quantities. The printed list includes the Caledonian Hunt for 100 copies and Creech for 500. In March Burns told Frances Dunlop that the intended printing had grown and that he had printed 3,000 copies. He had finished correcting the poems, while the glossary and subscribers' list still required attention.5
Selling continued after Burns left the city. On 17 May 1787, writing from Berrywell near Duns, he acknowledged a Paisley bookseller's payment of £22 7s for ninety copies, after carriage had been deducted. He explained that subscribers whose names had been omitted from the list should still receive the subscription price. Other buyers paid six shillings. With Creech away in London, his clerk Peter Hill could fulfil orders. The letter shows the practical work behind the imposing printed list: dispatching copies, allowing for transport, correcting omissions and directing customers to the person who could help.6
Friendship, gifts and the Crochallan Fencibles
Smellie and Hill also belonged to Burns's social life. So did the lawyer William Dunbar, who gave him volumes of Spenser. Burns answered with some of his own poems and a letter of thanks. As his departure approached, he wondered which Edinburgh friendships would survive distance and hoped Dunbar's would endure.7
Dunbar held the mock military title of colonel in the Crochallan Fencibles, a convivial club associated with Daniel Douglas's tavern in Anchor Close. Its name combined a Gaelic song sung by the landlord with the language of volunteer military companies. Its gatherings offered a setting for drinking, wit and song.8
Burns kept this circle in mind after moving to Ellisland. In an undated letter accompanying an ewe-milk cheese sent to Hill, he imagined portions being shared among their acquaintances. Smellie, James Candlish, the newspaper printer David Ramsay, Dunbar and Alexander Cunningham all came into the joke. Burns teased Dunbar about the wine consumed at a Crochallan gathering and praised Smellie's abilities, generosity and wit. A parcel of food became a way of renewing a group of friendships.7
A memorial for Fergusson
During the first winter Burns also sought a lasting place for another poet in Edinburgh. On 6 February 1787 he asked permission to mark Robert Fergusson's grave in the Canongate kirkyard. Fergusson's Scots poetry had encouraged his own writing. Burns wanted readers to be able to find the burial place and offered to provide a stone.9
The managers of the kirk and kirkyard funds granted permission on 22 February. The memorial took longer: the architect Robert Burn completed it in 1789. Burns supplied an epitaph as well as commissioning the work. The project connected his own success with the memory of a writer he admired, making a place in the city where later readers could pay their respects.9
Returning to the city
Edinburgh served as a base between the journeys of 1787. Burns travelled through the Borders in May, visited the western Highlands in June and set out with William Nicol on a longer northern tour in August. Later in the year he was staying with the schoolmaster William Cruikshank in St James's Square. In October he gave that address to James Hoy at Gordon Castle; in February 1788 he described Cruikshank as his host.10
The second winter produced a great deal of musical work. Burns collected material for James Johnson's Scots Musical Museum, asked friends for songs and discussed authorship, tunes and publication. On 14 February 1788 he told the songwriter John Skinner that the second volume had appeared that day and sent him a copy. He also asked for more material. The friendships made or renewed in Edinburgh supplied work that would continue after Burns moved south.11
An injured leg restricted his movements in December. On the 12th he told Margaret Chalmers that he was under a surgeon's care after a fall involving a drunken coachman. During this period he began an intense correspondence with Agnes McLehose, whom he had recently met. Her poetry and letters gave him another absorbing exchange while he was confined to his lodgings.12
McLehose was separated from her husband. The letters show her concern about the terms of their friendship and Burns's efforts to describe and defend his feelings. On 20 December he responded to her objection to his addressing a married woman. By 28 December he was calling her Clarinda and discussing the attraction of literary names. He also told her that he had seen her only once. Their intimacy had developed substantially on paper.13
Waiting for the accounts
Throughout these months the book remained unfinished business. Burns's letters to Margaret Chalmers complained about delays in Creech's accounts. In March 1788 he was also negotiating his lease of Ellisland. On the 14th, writing from Edinburgh, he told Chalmers that the bargain with Miller had been completed the previous evening. By the 26th he was in Glasgow, reporting the strain of arranging the lease and working through the bookseller's accounts.14
Payments and accounts continued to occupy him after he had begun life at Ellisland. In August 1788 he told Cruikshank that Creech still owed him about £50. On 4 January 1789 he explained the position to John Moore. He expected to clear about £400, including £100 for copyright, but part still depended on a further settlement. He complained of the long delay in obtaining a statement and acknowledged that his judgement of Creech might be unfair.15
By 23 March 1789 the tone had changed. Burns told Moore that he had recently visited Edinburgh and finally settled with Creech, who had been amicable and fair at the end. The enlarged edition had funded a new stage of his life, but turning its sales into settled accounts had taken much longer than printing the book.16
References
[1] Burns to John Ballantyne, 24 February 1787, letter XLVII; G. Ross Roy, “How Many Copies Were Printed of Burns's Second (Edinburgh) Edition?” (2012), publication context. Cunningham's 1855 edition; Roy's discussion.
[2] Burns to Ballantyne, 13 December 1786, XXXVI; Blacklock to George Lawrie in Currie, Works (1800), II, pp. 37–39. Burns's letter; Currie's volume.
[3] J. G. Lockhart, Life of Robert Burns (1828), p. 109 and footnote. Scanned volume.
[4] Burns, Poems (Edinburgh, 1787), frontispiece and title; Craig Lamont, A Bibliography of Robert Burns for the 21st Century: 1786–1802 (2017), pp. 6–8. 1787 volume; bibliography.
[5] Poems (1787), subscribers, pp. ix, xviii; Burns to Dunlop, 22 March 1787, in William Wallace, Robert Burns and Mrs. Dunlop (1898), I, pp. 19–21. Correspondence.
[6] Burns to Patison, 17 May 1787, LXII. Letter.
[7] Burns to Dunbar, LIX, undated; to Hill, CXXVII, undated. Dunbar letter; Hill letter.
[8] Robert Burns Encyclopedia, “Crochallan Fencibles”. Entry.
[9] Currie, Works, II, pp. 66–69; National Trust for Scotland, Burns's petition, 6 February 1787, NTS/02/25/BRN/01/41. Scanned volume; petition record.
[10] Burns to Hoy, 20 October 1787, LXXXII; Lockhart, pp. 144–162; Burns to Skinner, 14 February 1788, C. Hoy letter; Skinner letter.
[11] Burns to Skinner, 14 February 1788, C, cited above.
[12] Burns to Chalmers, 12 December 1787, XCI; National Trust for Scotland, letter to McLehose, 12 December 1787, NTS/02/25/BRN/01/125. Chalmers letter; McLehose letter.
[13] Burns to McLehose, 20 and 28 December 1787, NTS/02/25/BRN/01/126–127. 20 December; 28 December.
[14] Burns to Chalmers, CIX, 14 March 1788, and CXIV, undated; to Richard Brown, CX, 26 March 1788. Lease letter; accounts complaint; Brown letter.
[15] Burns to Cruikshank, August 1788, CXXIX; to Moore, 4 January 1789, CXLVI. Cruikshank letter; Moore letter.
[16] Burns to Moore, 23 March 1789, CLIII. Letter.