The boy who knew the poet’s name
Walter Scott was fifteen when he saw Robert Burns at Professor Ferguson’s house in Edinburgh. Among the guests were men of literary reputation, including Dugald Stewart. The younger people sat quietly, watching and listening. Scott already admired Burns’s poetry and longed to know him; an earlier promise of an introduction had come to nothing.[1]
He placed the meeting during Burns’s first Edinburgh visit, in 1786–87. The account he eventually sent to John Gibson Lockhart was written in 1827, about forty years afterwards.[1][2]
A picture and a remembered poem
Scott recalled a print by Bunbury showing a soldier lying dead in the snow. Beside him were his dog and his widow, with a child in her arms. Beneath the picture were verses describing the mother’s tears falling as she fed her baby. The passage ended:
Gave the sad presage of his future years,
The child of misery baptized in tears.
The lines imagined the hardship awaiting a child whose father had been killed. Scott remembered Burns being moved to tears by the picture and the ideas it suggested. Burns asked who had written the accompanying verse.[1]
Scott knew the answer: Langhorne. He whispered it to a friend, who passed the information to Burns. The acknowledgement came back as “a look and a word”. Scott described it as ordinary courtesy, yet he still remembered the pleasure it had given him. In a room where he had been listening to his elders, something he had read allowed him to contribute.[1]
What the boy remembered
Scott’s account gives Burns a strong physical presence. He remembered a robust man, plainly dressed, whose face seemed more substantial than the portraits suggested. His most striking detail was the dark eye that brightened when Burns spoke with feeling or interest.[1]
Burns appeared at ease in that company. Scott recalled him speaking confidently and expressing disagreement firmly, with modesty. He also remembered Burns talking of Allan Ramsay and Robert Fergusson as his models, with a humility Scott thought excessive.[1]
Scott was candid about the limits of his memory: he could no longer quote any of the conversation distinctly. The remembered gesture, the tears and the manner of speaking had lasted longer than the words.[1]
After the gathering, Scott saw Burns again in the street. Burns did not recognise him, which Scott thought entirely understandable. For the fifteen-year-old, a passing acknowledgement had become a memory he could still describe four decades later.[1]
References
[1] Walter Scott’s recollection, printed as an extract from his letter in J. G. Lockhart, Life of Robert Burns (Edinburgh: Constable and Co.; London: Hurst, Chance, and Co., 1828), pp. 112–115. The meeting and verse identification appear on pp. 112–113; appearance, conversation and the later street sighting on pp. 114–115. The quoted verse follows this printed witness. Read the scanned biography.
[2] J. G. Lockhart, Memoirs of the Life of Sir Walter Scott, Bart., volume I, chapter V, pp. 136–138, in the Lord Byron and his Times transcription. Lockhart dates the letter addressed to him to 1827 and reprints the account. Read the account and its introduction.