Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

A new prospect in Edinburgh

Thomas Blacklock found two different kinds of pleasure in Burns’s first book: the feeling and delicacy of the serious poems, and the wit and humour of the livelier ones. Writing to the Reverend George Lawrie in September 1786, he wanted the poems to reach more readers. He had heard that copies were already exhausted and urged a second edition, larger than the first.[1][2]

Blacklock was a poet himself, blind since infancy. His letter describes an earlier encounter with Burns’s work through the voice of Professor Dugald Stewart, who had read three poems to him. Blacklock had asked Stewart to put his name among the subscribers. Now, after completing his reading of the collection, he wanted to help its author find a wider audience.[1][2]

Praise that could travel

Lawrie had brought the poems to Blacklock’s attention. Stewart had read some aloud. Blacklock proposed getting a copy to Hugh Blair through a mutual friend. He believed that the poems’ quality, joined with the efforts of Burns’s friends, could secure an unusually wide circulation. Each reader could bring the work within reach of another.[1]

Currie, who printed the letter in 1800, explains how its encouragement travelled back to Burns: Lawrie sent a copy to Gavin Hamilton, who passed it on to the poet. Currie says that copy was found among Burns’s papers.[1]

This mattered at a moment when his plans were unsettled. In his later autobiographical letter to John Moore, Burns connected the first book with preparations to leave Scotland for Jamaica, where the proposed employment involved supervising enslaved labour. He remembered Blacklock’s letter opening fresh prospects for his poetic ambition. Here was approval from a critic whose praise he had scarcely dared to expect, and with it the hope of encouragement for another edition in Edinburgh.[3]

The practical problem remained how to produce that edition. As Three shillings for a poet explains, Burns reported that John Wilson would print again if he advanced the money for paper. The new encouragement made Edinburgh a place where he might find further help.[3][4]

Trying Edinburgh

In a letter of 18 November, Burns told Robert Muir that he was thinking of setting out for Edinburgh later that month. Currie places the journey in November. By December, Burns was writing from the city about introductions, supporters and negotiations for his next book.[3][4]

His letter to John Ballantyne reports friendship from Dalrymple of Orangefield and an introduction to Lord Glencairn. It also names Stewart, Blair and Henry Mackenzie among his literary friends. Burns said he was nearly agreed with William Creech to print the book and expected to send subscription bills home. The business of gathering readers, familiar from Kilmarnock, was beginning again among a wider circle.[4]

Public attention brought uneasiness as well as opportunity. In the same letter, Burns worried about being drawn too suddenly into the glare of fashionable and learned notice. In February 1787 he told Lawrie that novelty accounted for much of his present celebrity, and imagined the tide of attention receding.[4]

Blacklock, meanwhile, had become someone he saw often. Burns described him to Lawrie as possessing “a clear head and an excellent heart”. The praise that had once arrived as a copied letter had developed into personal acquaintance.[4]

References

[1] Thomas Blacklock to the Reverend G. Lawrie, in James Currie, The Works of Robert Burns (1800), volume II, letter X, pp. 37–39, including Currie’s note on its transmission. Read the scanned volume.

[2] University of Glasgow, The Letters of James Currie, editorial note on Thomas Blacklock accompanying John Ramsay’s letter of 14 July 1799. The note dates Blacklock’s letter to 4 September 1786 and supplies biographical context. Read the correspondence and notes.

[3] Robert Burns’s autobiographical letter to John Moore and Currie’s account of the Edinburgh journey, in James Currie, The Works of Robert Burns (1800), volume I, pp. 54–56 and 135–136. Read the scanned volume.

[4] Robert Burns, letters to Robert Aiken, Robert Muir (18 November 1786), John Ballantyne (printed as 13 December 1786) and George Lawrie (5 February 1787), in Allan Cunningham’s The Complete Works of Robert Burns (1855), correspondence XXI, XXXIII, XXXVI and XLV, pp. 326–328, 332, 333–334 and 338. Read the edition’s ebook transcription.