The friend who heard a poet
On 30 December 1787, Burns wrote from Edinburgh to Richard Brown and reminded him of a Sunday they had spent together in Eglinton woods. Burns had recited some verses. Brown had wondered why he resisted the temptation to send work of such merit to a magazine. Years afterwards, Burns could still explain what the remark had done for him: it had changed his estimate of his own writing and encouraged him to pursue the character of a poet.[1]
Burns formed this friendship during his time at Irvine, where he had gone to learn flax-dressing in 1781–82. That venture ended after a shop fire, as the Irvine story describes. His account of the town also gives considerable space to a young seaman whose experience and independence impressed him. Cunningham identifies this friend as Brown.[1][2]
A listener whose opinion mattered
In the autobiographical letter to John Moore, Burns described the seaman as the son of a mechanic, educated with a patron’s help, then driven to sea after the patron died. He had experienced reversals of fortune, including being put ashore in Ireland by an American privateer. Burns admired his generosity and independence and felt that his knowledge of the world far exceeded his own. These were the qualities Burns remembered when he explained his eagerness to learn from him.[2]
Brown’s opinion of the verses therefore came from someone whose judgement Burns valued. The suggestion was practical: send them to a magazine. In Burns’s account, an appreciative listener made him consider readers beyond the people who already knew him.[1][2]
The conversation survives through that later recollection. His account to Moore describes further influences on the writing, including the renewed energy he found in Robert Fergusson’s Scots poetry. Brown’s encouragement helped him take his writing more seriously.[2]
Remembering the friendship
In the same December letter, Burns also wrote about their friendship. He was delighted that Brown’s fortunes had improved and said his friend’s story and outlook had helped strengthen him against his own troubles. A bruised limb was delaying Burns’s return to Ayrshire, but he hoped they would meet when he could travel. He sent his regards to Mrs Brown and pictured his old companion settled into the responsibilities of husband and father.[1]
Two years later, writing from Ellisland on 4 November 1789, Burns again tried to arrange a visit. Excise work was keeping him busy across ten parishes, and obtaining time away would require permission. He asked Brown to come to him before going back to sea. The letter proposed visits between their households and the additional pleasure of their wives getting to know one another.[1]
Burns called Brown his earliest surviving friend apart from his brothers. He imagined their shared misfortunes as having entwined them like growing branches, and proposed a toast: “May the companions of our youth be the friends of our old age!” The man who had once listened to his verses was someone with whom he still wanted to share a day, a drink and the news from home.[1]
References
[1] Robert Burns, letters to Richard Brown, 30 December 1787 and 4 November 1789, in Allan Cunningham’s edition, The Complete Works of Robert Burns (1855), correspondence XCV and CLXXV, pp. 368–369 and 412–413; including Cunningham’s introductory identification of Brown. Read the edition’s ebook transcription.
[2] Robert Burns, autobiographical letter to John Moore, 2 August 1787, in James Currie, The Works of Robert Burns (1800), volume I, pp. 50–52. Read the scanned volume.