Burns, the smugglers and the four cannon
On 29 February 1792, Robert Burns led one of three parties towards an armed smuggling vessel in the Solway Firth. The officers and soldiers had to approach through the water. The ship was firing, the current was strong, and attempts to find boats had failed. Walter Crawfurd, the riding officer whose journal describes the operation, recorded men wading breast-high before the crew abandoned the vessel and escaped towards the English shore.[1]
The seizure took place at Sarkfoot, near Gretna, where the river Sark meets the Solway. A newspaper report published the following week described revenue officers from Dumfries working with dragoons. It reported gunfire and the smugglers’ flight, and praised the military commander, Quartermaster Manly. Crawfurd’s journal supplies Burns’s place in the operation: he commanded the party approaching the vessel’s broadside.[1]
The alarm had come on the evening of 27 February. Crawfurd received word that a landing was being made or was about to begin, and set off with his fellow officer John Lewars, leaving Burns and two other officers to follow. By the next day the vessel was held in shallow water. Crawfurd attempted to approach with soldiers, then went aboard alone after the men on deck threatened to fire. He counted twenty-four armed men. The officers decided that they needed reinforcements.[1]
By nine on the morning of the 29th, forty-four dragoons had assembled from Dumfries, Annan and Ecclefechan. The vessel had moved farther down the firth, and a strong stream lay between it and the officers. Crawfurd says local people guessed that the party would seek boats and damaged them before the officers could reach them. Quicksands made an approach on horseback dangerous. They decided to try the crossing on foot, provided the stream could be forded.[1]
The soldiers divided into three parties, led by Manly, Crawfurd and Burns. Their orders were to hold their fire until close to the ship and then board with sword and pistol. Crawfurd reported that the vessel’s position prevented its large guns from bearing effectively on them. When the attackers came within about a hundred yards, the smugglers went over the far side and made for the dry sand towards England. The officers continued their advance, expecting resistance, and found the ship deserted. Crawfurd identified her as the Roseomond of Plymouth; the sale papers call her the Rosamond.[1]
Taking possession left a considerable job to do. The smugglers had damaged the vessel before leaving, and heavy rain brought flooding that strained her timbers. An expense account largely in Burns’s handwriting describes the effort at the pumps and the wait for a spring tide to float her. Carpenters and seamen worked on her; dragoons and excise officers remained aboard. The officers also feared an attempt to recover the ship.[1]
The advertised sale was at the Coffee House in Dumfries on 19 April. The vessel lay at Kelton, where prospective buyers could inspect her. Among the listed equipment were four four-pounder carronades, mounted on carriages, with their tackle and ammunition. The account of the sale records £4 2s. 6d. for guns. It names no buyer for them.[1]
Those guns acquired a second life in Burns’s biography. In 1828, John Gibson Lockhart wrote that Burns bought four carronades and sent them, with a letter expressing admiration and respect, to the French Convention. Customs officers at Dover, he said, intercepted the gift. Lockhart connected this supposed action with the suspicion later directed at Burns’s political opinions. His telling made an officer enforcing British revenue law into a man supplying revolutionary France with cannon.[2]
The evidence for that sequel remains much weaker than the evidence for the capture. Joseph Train, an antiquary and excise officer who supplied material to Lockhart and Walter Scott, said that John Lewars had left a document describing Burns’s purchase. When Henry Meikle published the surviving capture and sale papers in 1934, that document had not been found. Searches of surviving Customs records reported in Meikle’s article had also failed to establish the Dover seizure.[1]
Gerard Carruthers and Ralph McLean revisited the story in 2022 and judged the shipment to France highly unlikely on the surviving evidence. There are specific problems in Lockhart’s telling. He put the auction on the day after the capture; the advertisement gives 19 April. His intended recipient, the French Convention, only came into existence in September. They also suggest that the story may have borrowed from Professor John Anderson’s documented involvement with artillery in France.[3]
Lockhart condemned the alleged gift as a breach of decorum. Carruthers and McLean trace its later appeal to admirers who saw in it evidence of Burns’s revolutionary commitment. The same cannon story could serve both condemnation and admiration, while the documents establishing who bought the guns and what happened to them remained missing.[2][3]
References
[1] Henry W. Meikle, ‘Burns and the Capture of the Rosamond’, Burns Chronicle and Club Directory, second series, vol. IX (1934), pp. 43–52: contemporary newspaper report, p. 43; Crawfurd’s journal, pp. 47–48; expenses and sale papers, pp. 49–50, with a manuscript facsimile; history of the cannon claim and searches, pp. 44–46, 50–52.
[2] J. G. Lockhart, Life of Robert Burns (1828), pp. 218–219. Digitised copy.
[3] Gerard Carruthers and Ralph McLean, ‘Did Burns Send Cannon to France in 1792? — A New Theory of the Narrative’, Burns Chronicle 131.2 (2022), pp. 139–155; open-access accepted manuscript, pp. 1–6, 10. University of Glasgow repository.