Skip to content
Robert Burns Home Search

The play Robert Burns wanted to burn

John Murdoch brought a copy of Shakespeare’s Titus Andronicus as a parting gift for the Burns family. When the family asked him to stop reading, Robert threatened to burn the play. His younger brother Gilbert recalled the evening years later.[1]

Five families around Alloway had engaged John Murdoch to teach their children and took turns giving him board. He taught Robert and Gilbert to read and write. Murdoch remembered making the boys work out the meaning of every word in the verses they learned, while Gilbert recalled Robert seeking out whatever books he could find. Murdoch lent him a Life of Hannibal, the first book Robert read beyond his schoolbooks. Books were hard to come by, and a Life of Wallace reached him only some years later, borrowed from the blacksmith who shod the family’s horses.[1]

The Burnes family moved to the farm at Mount Oliphant. Its distance from Murdoch’s school made regular attendance difficult, and Murdoch eventually left the district. Before going to Carrick, he spent a night with the family. He brought a small compendium of English grammar and a copy of Titus Andronicus as parting gifts, then began to read the play aloud.[1][2]

The family listened until the story reached the mutilation of Lavinia. Gilbert remembered that her hands had been cut off and her tongue cut out. The listeners cried and asked Murdoch to stop. William Burnes said there was little use in leaving a play they could not bear to hear through. Robert replied that, if it were left, he would burn it. William was about to chide him for answering a teacher’s gift in that way, but Murdoch approved their response. He left a comedy, The School for Love, in its place.[1]

Gilbert told the story as an example of his brother’s childhood character. Currie, who printed the account in 1800, reckoned Robert was about nine. Gilbert also remembered what followed Murdoch’s departure: with the boys needed on the farm and no nearby school, their father taught arithmetic to the children on winter evenings by candlelight. He borrowed books on geography, astronomy and natural history for them, and talked with the boys as they worked beside him. Gilbert recalled Robert reading those books avidly.[1]

References

[1] Gilbert Burns, letter to Mrs Dunlop, James Currie’s editorial note, and John Murdoch’s account of teaching the brothers, in James Currie, ed., The Works of Robert Burns; with an Account of His Life, vol. I (Liverpool: J. M’Creery, 1800), pp. 60–65, 89–92. Digitised copy.

[2] Royal Shakespeare Company, Titus Andronicus: dates and sources.